Excerpt

The wand was in her vagina. She had a vagina. She had hands, legs, lungs, a face with features that changed depending on her emotional state. A womb, containing an embryo she had been gestating for nine weeks and four days. Her husband, a regular man, stood at her side. The image of her uterus appeared on the screen, black, white, and grainy, like footage from the moon. And there, inside it, was the baby—though they weren’t calling it a baby yet—in a position as though lying in a hammock, a spectral reverse silhouette. It reminded her of Casper the Friendly Ghost, a cartoon she’d watched as a child. She had been a child.

“If I’m silent,” the doctor said, “it doesn’t mean anything’s wrong.”

Silently the doctor moved the wand inside her. Silence didn’t mean anything was wrong, but she thought to herself, silently, that something did seem wrong.

A minute later the doctor confirmed it. Not only was something wrong; the most wrong thing had happened: the baby’s heart had stopped beating.

Rachel Khong

Rachel Khong is the author of Goodbye, Vitamin, winner of the California Book Award for First Fiction. Real Americans, her second novel, was a New York Times bestseller. In 2018, Khong founded The Ruby, a work and event space for women and nonbinary writers and artists in San Francisco’s Mission District. With friends, she teaches creative writing in a collective called The Dream Side. She lives in Los Angeles. Her story collection, My Dear You, will be published by Knopf in April 2026.

Will Allison on “Colors from Elsewhere”

I enjoy stories that upend my expectations, and this month’s story did it again and again. As Rachel Khong’s “Colors from Elsewhere” opens, a young Chinese-American woman learns that her unborn child’s heart has stopped beating. The next few pages—by turns heartbreaking and hilarious—explore the difficulty of losing a child, the ways it affects one’s self-perception as well as how one is perceived by others.

But just as I was settling in for what was shaping up to be a brilliant story about the aftermath of a miscarriage, I came to this scene, the protagonist’s follow-up visit with her doctor:

“Any other questions?” the doctor asked.

Her discharge had seemed strange. She figured it was the result of putting eight pills in her vagina to expel the “products of conception.” The color of the fluid she produced had been shocking: green one day, violet the next, eventually cycling through all the colors of the rainbow.

“My discharge is yellow,” she said, which was true: it was yellow at the moment. She didn’t mention that, last night, it had been indigo.

The protagonist’s colorful discharge is the first hint that things aren’t quite what they seem, and sure enough, seven pages later, the story serves up an even bigger revelation, which I can’t describe here without spoiling things. (Tip: hold off reading the Q&A below if you want to avoid spoilers.)

Suffice it to say, what begins as a realist story becomes something quite different, and what begins as a story about losing a baby ends up being about so much more: what it means to be an immigrant, what it means to be different from other people, which differences really matter in the grand scheme of things, and, ultimately, what it means to be human (sort of).

If that all sounds a bit heavy theme-wise, fear not. In Ms. Khong’s deft hands, the story wears its themes with casual assurance, keeping its focus squarely on the mystery of the protagonist’s condition. So sit back and prepare to be intrigued. Prepare to be entertained. And most of all, prepare to be transported in ways you probably aren’t expecting.

Q&A by Will Allison

WA: What initially inspired you to write “Colors from Elsewhere”?
RK: Well, frankly, a miscarriage that I had in the fall of 2023. It was a terrible and strange kind of grief that I had never experienced before—a grieving of possibility, strange and isolating, for as common as the experience is. For me, inspiration often comes in the form of an ineffable question I have, or an experience of living. Whenever I think, This is weird, or This is fucked up—there might be a story lurking there.
WA: What was the most challenging part of writing this story?
RK: The hardest part was writing through sadness. Though I wrote the first page just days into the miscarriage, I needed to let the story become itself, not just a narration of what had happened to me. I’m not interested in writing autobiography; I’m interested in making art. What made it possible to finish the story was time, and holding the story and its protagonist very loosely in my mind. It took time to gain the proper distance from the event itself, and to see the story on its own terms. In writing, I’ve found there’s some kind of transformation that needs to happen that cannot be forced. In fiction, there’s a difference between accuracy and truth. What matters isn’t “This really happened,” but what feels true.
WA: And what was the most satisfying part?
RK: It’s always the most satisfying when the characters come alive, and the story transforms into itself—into the story that wants to exist. It’s satisfying to sense the protagonist becoming a real person. She has become, in my mind, not only as real as the other fictional characters I’ve written, but as real as my friends, my family.
WA: This story begins as a work of ostensibly realist fiction, but it takes a turn on page 4, and by page 11, it’s well into a sci-fi/speculative/magical-realist realm. Did you always know the story was headed in that direction, or was it something you discovered in the course of writing?
RK: I rarely know what’s going to happen in a piece of writing when I begin writing it. I didn’t know the full story, but the moment I wrote the first sentences of “Colors from Elsewhere,” I knew that the protagonist was an alien. I had been turning the phrase it’s so common over in my mind. Also the word minority. Having a miscarriage was statistically in the minority. I’m a minority in America, though there are ~1.42 billion Chinese people on the planet. And, like the protagonist, I had a laminated card as a kid that said I was a “resident alien.” Miscarriages are never fully explained; most likely, they’re the result of chromosomal abnormalities. But I wondered: What if this particular miscarriage had a very real explanation?
WA: On one level, this is a story about pregnancy. On another level, it’s a story about what it means to be an immigrant. And on yet another level, it’s a story about our shared humanity (courtesy of a non-human protagonist). I love that the narrative manages to do so much, so well, in such a short space. Were you ever tempted to make this into a novel?
RK: One of my biggest pet peeves is when people take premises or ideas that should have been short stories and turn them into novels. Capitalism (and critics!) love this kind of novel because it’s graspable, manageable, marketable; I disagree. I think a novel should be resistant to the elevator pitch: the best kind of novel is the kind where you read the summary of it, then read the novel itself and feel misled—even angry—because you find the summary woefully insufficient. The novel is so much richer and more complicated than what the back cover promises; it defies summary. I love a novel that is bursting with questions, and I love a story that is bursting with questions. That’s how life feels to me; life never has one “theme” that we’re orbiting neatly. I love stories as a form, and I love pushing what they can do, and contain. Stories can feel complete—nearly perfect—in a way that novels rarely can. Novels always show their seams and imperfections, and I don’t necessarily think perfection is the goal. Novels are really unwieldy for human writers—they are an insane artistic exertion—and that’s what I love about them, too.
WA: Not only is the story’s protagonist unnamed; none of the characters are. Why?
RK: In writing there are so many decisions that happen just because it “feels right.” Audre Lorde writes about this in Uses of the Erotic: “It feels right to me.” Writing anything is so much about trying to tap into the feeling of rightness, which is intuited and bodily. When naming characters, names can often feel really fake until you stumble upon just the right one. With “Colors from Elsewhere,” it felt right that the protagonist did not have a name. Or rather, she had one that we weren’t privy to. It would have felt false to give her one.
WA: “Colors from Elsewhere” will appear in your story collection, My Dear You, due out in April. Could you talk about how this story fits into the collection?
RK: It wasn’t until after I assembled the stories that I saw preoccupations and themes I hadn’t really been aware of while writing each individual story. This is going to sound really unglamorous, but My Dear You is a collection that’s about coming to terms with the limits of life—with growing older, with realizing we can’t do everything we want, or be anyone we want. In “Colors from Elsewhere,” the protagonist mourns the futures she might have had. My Dear You, the collection, is very much about this, too. It’s about how the lives we live foreclose on other lives and possibilities; how having limits is perhaps the defining aspect of humanity (one day, we’ll all be dead). At the same time, fiction is one way we push against those limits; while reading, we get to expand our lives.
WA: How long did it take you to complete “Colors from Elsewhere”?
RK: Nine months. (Ha. I had no idea until answering this question and calculated the process from first sentence to completion. I completed the story around the time of my would-be due date. I guess instead of a baby, I got this story.)
WA: What are you working on now?
RK: I underwent two cycles of IVF in 2025, and it was perhaps the hardest, most bizarre thing I’ve ever experienced. So I’m working on a zine about the year that I’m calling Lizard Brain: an infertilizine. I’m going to spiral bind a limited number of copies. If you’re interested in learning more, I send updates through my newsletter, as well as monthly short story recommendations. I’m also working on my third novel, which I’ve been writing for about three years now but still feels nascent. So I can’t quite talk about it yet. Let’s just say that it’s polyphonic, and it’s about the classical element of air, which is also associated with knowledge, metal, and communication.
WA: What is the best bit of writing advice you’ve ever received?
RK: The truest advice is this: if you want to write, you have to read. Read a lot and read everything. The advice I had in mind while finishing this story, specifically, was: “Just write the fun parts.” Though it’s about a horrible occurrence, I did have fun.