The Bet
$2.50
Excerpt
There were brilliant people at the entrepreneur’s party, as brilliant as one could gather in Austin before Covid and the influx of the coastal elites. The group was small, no more than ten or twelve people: a few McKinsey consultants, a couple of early-stage VCs, some corporate execs from Dell and Whole Foods, a journalist for the American-Statesman, two UT McCombs MBAs, and even a philosophy professor from UT. The wine and liquor flowed freely, and many interesting topics were debated, the types of discussions you can have only among the highly educated, the intellectual, and most importantly, the successful. The entrepreneur, then forty years old, was celebrating his first large exit. He felt relieved, happy, and impressed by his own success, and he looked forward to a life of gatherings like this.
Among other things, the group talked at length about whether it was better in life to run “loose” or “tight.” It started out as a lighthearted discussion after the entrepreneur commented that running his company “loosely” was his secret: He never worked more than forty hours a week, never drove his teams too hard, never got upset about missing a target; he enjoyed life as much as he could and believed brilliance, charisma, and a bit of luck were what it took to be successful.
“I don’t agree with you,” said one of the young McCombs MBAs.
Nick Spitzman
Nick Spitzman (nickspitzman.com) is a fiction writer and recovering tech executive. Originally from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, he is now based in Austin, Texas. His work has appeared or is forthcoming in ExPat Press, The Berlin Literary Review, and elsewhere. He received an honorable mention from Glimmer Train, participated in the 2026 Disquiet International Literary Program, and will be a spring 2027 resident at the Vermont Studio Center.
Will Allison on “The Bet”
In Anton Chekhov’s 1889 short story “The Bet,” a wealthy banker and a young lawyer debate the relative morality of the death penalty and life imprisonment.
For his part, the banker asserts that capital punishment is preferable. “Execution kills instantly,” he says. “Life-imprisonment kills by degrees. Who is the more humane executioner, one who kills you in a few seconds, or one who draws the life out of you slowly, for years?”
The lawyer, on the other hand, says that the death penalty and life imprisonment are equally immoral, because the goal of both is to take away life. “The state is not God,” he says. “It has no right to take away that which it cannot give back.” But he goes on to say that if he had to choose, he would definitely choose life in prison, because to live at all is better than not living.
The debate culminates with the banker betting the lawyer $20 million that he can’t survive fifteen years in solitary confinement.
In this month’s story, “The Bet,” by Nick Spitzman, the setup is more or less the same, but the bet is different, involving a philosophical debate about whether it’s preferable to run “loose” or run “tight” in one’s work—a subject close to Mr. Spitzman’s heart, as he spent twenty years running tight in his former career as a tech executive.
I found Spitzman’s story to be a worthy companion piece to Chekhov’s original. Though Spitzman brings the story into the twenty-first century, he manages to retain a Chekhovian feel in terms of tone and voice. And if I may say so, I think Spitzman improves upon the original by dispensing with Chekhov’s frame story in favor of a tauter chronological telling.
In addition to making me glad that I’m not much of a gambler, the story definitely got me thinking about my own work/life balance and the choices my wife and I have made vis-à-vis our careers and personal lives. In the end, though, I’m still not sure if my twenty-year-old self would have taken the bet or not.
How about you, One Story reader? Would you devote ten years of your life to nothing but work in exchange for $20 million? And will your answer be the same after reading this month’s story? There’s only one way to find out.
Q&A by Will Allison
- WA: What inspired you to write “The Bet”?
- NS: I spent most of my life “running tight” for the sake of financial security. I spent twenty years in a career as a hard-charging business executive, which I did not always love. During those twenty years, I thought a lot about how an unfulfilling career can be very much like a self-imposed prison. I reread Chekhov’s “The Bet” (one of my favorite stories), and the idea for my story came to me, mixing all of these themes.
- WA: What was the most challenging part of writing this story?
- NS: Figuring out which parts of Chekhov’s original concept made sense to keep and which I had to discard or adapt. The original is brilliant, but it was not meant to illustrate the concepts I intended my story to illustrate. For instance, the price of “running tight” or the Faustian bargain of exchanging years of your life for financial security are not themes in the original.
- WA: And what was the most satisfying part?
- NS: I wrote this story last year as I was thinking about leaving my job as an executive. I felt that it really encapsulated what I had just gone through after twenty years in a business career. So it was like writing a story for my twenty-two-year-old self, who was about to start out in that career after college, running very tight.
- WA: “The Bet” involves a wager between a wealthy entrepreneur and a poor, up-and-coming MBA student. At the story’s core is a philosophical question about the role of work in our lives, namely, whether it’s better to run loose or run tight, as the story puts it. What would your answer be?
- NS: As I mentioned, I ran very tight my whole life. Now, at forty-two, I feel like it was the right call, given my personal circumstances and what I thought I needed to achieve first, to now be able to run looser. So in retrospect, it worked out, and I’m grateful for that. Of course, I recognize that while it was the right call for me, it’s not necessarily right for everyone.
- WA: When did you start writing fiction?
- NS: In college I took a couple of fiction-writing classes with Alice Mattison and Caryl Phillips, two award-winning authors. I loved it. I was majoring in literature, so I loved fiction already, but that was the first time I tried writing some myself.
- WA: Can you talk about how your business career has influenced or affected your writing?
- NS: On the positive side, it gave me the freedom to now be able to dedicate myself to writing. It also gave me lots of material, as it afforded me incredible opportunities to live and travel internationally, and personal and professional growth I might not have had otherwise. On the negative side, when you’re running super tight in a business career, there is little time or emotional energy for writing. That was the biggest downside. I feel like I’m making up for lost time now.
- WA: How long did it take you to finish this story?
- NS: I finished the first draft over a weekend. I was still working as an executive, so I felt pressure to finish it before returning to work on Monday, which was probably a good thing. I then refined the draft over time.
- WA: What are you working on now?
- NS: I’ve begun working on my first novel, which is quite daunting but exciting as a new challenge. Occasionally when I need a break from the novel or feel inspired by another idea, I write a new short story. Interestingly, after twenty years of feeling guilty for not writing short stories, I now sometimes feel guilty when I do write short stories, because it’s time I should be devoting to the novel.
- WA: What is the best bit of writing advice you’ve ever received?
- NS: There are lots of versions of this one, but basically, it’s to just get the finished draft on the page and not worry about the quality at first. I think this is brilliant advice for two reasons. First, you have no idea what’s good or not as you are writing it. You can judge it or refine it later. Second, focusing on the output before focusing on quality is a way to make sure you are “coming to the page” more often, instead of just when you feel inspired. This keeps you engaged as a writer, keeps your subconscious working on the story even when you are not writing. I think this is crucial.